JUMP TO SOLUTION Solved

Original topic:

No GPS data added to photos when transferred

(Topic created: 08-09-2023 01:14 AM)
stevef70
Asteroid
Options
Other Mobile Devices

Hi, I recently bought an A13 and I am delighted with it, but there is one small issue.

GPS location is not being added to the exif data. Pre-empting all those who want to ask, I'll confirm that :

  • Location service is on and working in google maps, OSMand, and other apps
  • Camera has permission to access location
  • Camera settings adjusted to add location data to pix

Curiously - and confirming that GPS is working - when viewing the images in the gallery on the phone, I can see a map with a pointer at the location where I took the pic. So the phone knows where it was taken, but when I transfer the pix to my laptop and examine the exif data, all GPS fields are empty.

So what else could it be? I think I've covered everything but I'm happy to be corrected if someone has an answer.

 

 
0 Likes
18 Replies
jj28
Astronaut
Options
Other Mobile Devices

Same issue with my A22. If I switch back to JPG format GPS data is added as expected

 

 
0 Likes
stevef70
Asteroid
Options
Other Mobile Devices

If you switch 'back' to JPG? What format were you using before that?

 

 

0 Likes
stevef70
Asteroid
Options
Other Mobile Devices

A couple of comments here mention the idea that the GPS data exists but is stripped when pix are transferred. I don't believe this is the case. For a start, that would require a special background program to be running which would have to identify events when pix are being transferred and modify them on the fly. It's not impossible, but it would add demand on the system and slow down transfers by a significant amount.

Secondly, I can browse my phone from my computer and examine the EXIF data in situ. It's all there, except for GPS data. So it's not that it's being stripped from the pix, it is not being added in the first place.

 

 

0 Likes
aj347
Asteroid
Options
Other Mobile Devices

Interesting point Steve.

Option 1/ Take picture, a jpg file is created along with another file. Open picture on phone and the phone pulls in the GPS data by linking the two files.

Q/ Where is this other file stored? I could go with this idea because other cameras create small thumb nail files when displaying multiple images.

Option 2/ Take picture, jpg file created with all camera settings including GPS.

Q/ If image stored on removable SD card then if I remove the SD card all the data should be there with the picture? And the phone wouldn't have any control over the file!

Could there be hidden file kept on internal memory, very possible!

But why not allow the user to do what ever they want. Or have a warning of the information being available.

 

 
0 Likes
aj347
Asteroid
Options
Other Mobile Devices

Problem solved!

The pictures that I have from a trip I took recently have all the location data attached. Had a conversation with a friend and he suggested to try a program call XnView. After removing my SD card from my A51 poped it into my pc, copied the files over to my backup drive I was able to see all the exif data including the GPS with sea level and all.

What a relief, so it seems to be the software that used to view the images that was the problem.

 

 
0 Likes
Solution
stevef70
Asteroid
Options
Other Mobile Devices

Thanks to @aj347's last comment, I've realised that I've been wrong on a couple of points in this discussion. 

I normally use an app installed on both my phone and my computer which allows me to very easily transfer files from one to another using a 'share' option when files are selected in the phone gallery, but I tried aj347's suggestion of removing the SD card and putting it in the computer - and sure enough, all the GPS data is there.

So the data is being written to the pix, but is stripped sometime during transfer. But by which - the phone or the app???

Using that same app I can browse the SD card from my computer while it is still in the phone, and transfer files just as in any other file manager such as Explorer. Transferring them that way preserves the GPS data. It's not as convenient as the old way, but it is a far better solution than turning the phone off, removing the card, etc etc etc.

Thanks to all for your input.

 

 
suiluispi
Astronaut
Options
Other Mobile Devices

Finally, after reading multiple posts I tried a different thing, and it worked:

1. Giving Location permissions to the camera and gallery apps.

2. Copy the images from the "file manager app" instead from the "gallery app" to your desired folder. In my case, I copied it into a Google folder.

3. Later, I checked (using Python) if the geolocation was provided and yes, it is there.

I tried several ways but this was the only way I could export the exif + geolocation.

0 Likes
suiluispi
Astronaut
Options
Other Mobile Devices

Finally, after reading multiple posts I tried a different thing, and it worked:

1. Giving Location permissions to the camera and gallery apps.

2. Copy the images from the "file manager app" instead from the "gallery app" to your desired folder. In my case, I copied it into a Google folder.

3. Later, I checked (using Python) if the geolocation was provided and yes, it is there.

I tried several ways but this was the only way I could export the exif + geolocation.

0 Likes
stevef70
Asteroid
Options
Other Mobile Devices

"Copy the images from the "file manager app" instead from the "gallery app" to your desired folder. In my case, I copied it into a Google folder."

Nice work suiluispi! That works for me too 👍

0 Likes