And when I check in Samsung contacts it says I have specific people set to "ask first" but the phone dialer isn't respecting this setting.
I can't imagine Samsung intends for it to work this way in Android 12.
For the time being I switched to Google Phone for my dialer and that has worked around this issue. Samsung, fix this problem.
Hello @Claykin ,
Thank you for your feedback. If you haven’t already, Please send us an error report from the Samsung member’s app -> Beta Feedback -> Error Reports to help us debug the issue. We apologize for the inconvenience and appreciate your contribution to the beta program.
One UI Beta Team