The only way to pair them is to send in to a repair center to be paired
If you've found my post to be helpful, Please like my Comments ✓✓✓. If my response resolved your issue, please press the Like and ✓✓✓ to Accept as Solution button.
@GaryB82 is correct. The Buds and charging cradle would need to serviced to be paired.
You can use the following link to find a list of service centers in the U.S. that can do the repair: http://www.samsung.com/us/support/service/location or by calling customer support at 1-800-726-7864.
